Discussions

Girls! Please Help Me Out! Which Guy Is Hotter?

Posted by ModelElaine • 9/24/08 • Subscribe to this Discussion [RSS] • Report This Topic
Topics: guy, Hot, vote, voting

I am running this survey because I have had a disagreement in a guy friend about which of this two guys is hotter. Please, help me out by voting! Scroll down to the voting poll to vote.

photo-book-reviews.blogspot.com/2008/09/which-guy-is-hotter.html

I am posting under Blog Promotion, but is really is not. It was my friend's idea to post on a forum and ask outside opinions because I and him disagree. Please, help me out! Thank you much!

User Comments

9/24/08

jan4insight

I voted for #1, which makes it a tie so far. Guess I didn't do much to help answer your question, ha ha.

[reply]
1. 9/24/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Thank you so much for participating! Now we got two to two. My friend and I are sitting tight waiting for more votes to come. Out of curiosity, what made you decide which person to pick?
2. 9/24/08
  
  jan4insight
  
  #1 had a more casual look, which appeals to me!
3. 9/24/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  What about the facial features? Say if guy #1 was dressed in a tux, and guy #2 was dressed down, would that affect your decision?
4. 9/25/08
  
  jan4insight
  
  No, because I also liked the hair on guy #1 better. That was part of his casual look that I liked.
9/24/08

poisonapplesauce

I voted #2

[reply]
1. 9/24/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Thank you! Same question for you. What made you decide on which person to pick?
2. 9/24/08
  
  poisonapplesauce
  
  well at first I thought they looked related, but the second one appeared to have fuller lips, which I have a thing for. also had a passion in his eyes, almost like he was fired up about something where as the first seemed to be more either confused or amused. It's hard to say with the expression but it just didn't scream hot to me
3. 9/25/08
  
  poisonapplesauce
  
  They are both a bit proper looking for me, I like down and dirty grungy guys, but # 2 had lips!
4. 9/25/08
  
  poisonapplesauce
  
  oops sorry already answered
9/24/08

cooper

I took 1.

[reply]
9/24/08

blackzero85

Hotter? The second one ftw!

I really like his eyes, seriously. And I can tell he's hotter while smiling.

[reply]
9/24/08

kathysq

I voted 1.

[reply]
9/24/08

ModelElaine

If you girls don't mind, please leave the reason for your pick in the comment section. My friend really wants to know the reasons behind the decision. Thank you all again!

[reply]
9/24/08

timethief

I voted for number 2 because we only had the two to choose from and I tossed a coin.
The second guy knows how to pose better IMO so his eyes look sexier.
However, neither have the kind of looks that I prefer.

[reply]
1. 9/24/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Thank you for your candor. I got you
2. 9/24/08
  
  timethief
  
  You're welcome. I saw what you said above and left a comment for you.
3. 9/24/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  thank you!
9/25/08

MadameX

I really don't think either one is attractive. #1 is less unattractive than #2, who looks very artificial, but I wasn't sure that was grounds to call him "hotter" so I didn't vote.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Voting for the least unattractive counts as well. timethief voted for the one who she thought was the least unattractive. I and my friend are in disagreement as to which one is hotter or which one is least hot for that matter. If you think that one is less unattractive than the other, vote for the one who is less unattractive, because the matter in question is not whether they are hot, but rather, which one is better looking and which one is uglier looking. We count all votes.
9/25/08

ModelElaine

So far I have had more votes than comments. If anyone has voted but not commented, please do so. I do appreciate your help in this contest. Thanks a lot!

[reply]
9/25/08

Sebastyne

I wouldn't touch either one with a long stick, but the #2 was better of the two. He looks untrustworthy, but I liked his bone structure more than the other ones. The other one has a really, really unattractive nose.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Thank you for participating and for your candor
9/25/08

acousticguitarist

hilarious

[reply]
9/25/08

blackzero85

Left comment on that post too, elaine.

[reply]
9/25/08

calais50

#2 wins easily for me. He is more classically attractive.

[reply]
9/25/08

craftymug

I voted for #1 and left a comment.

[reply]
9/25/08

CreativeJunkie

Neither one really does it for me, but I voted #1 because #2 looked a bit too plastic and fake for me.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  legbamel
  
  Yeah, number two looks like a smarmy punk, although that could be the over-styled hair and the pose. At least the first guy looks like a person you could sit down and have a nice talk with over coffee or wine.
2. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  legbamel,
  
  did you leave your vote and comment?
9/25/08

sulz

i voted for number one because he looks down-to-earth and more mature than number two, who looks like he might spend more time in the bathroom than me. he is handsome though, in that pose-y, model-y way.

[reply]
9/25/08

flamingpoodle

Nice to see ladies treat men like pieces of meat too.
Don't you love being objectified?

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  jan4insight
  
  What goes around comes around!
2. 9/25/08
  
  flamingpoodle
  
  Wasn't complaining, just noticing.
9/25/08

Katuluu

Neither seem to have the muscle strength in their necks to hold their head up straight, which would lead me to believe they both have fairly weak genes as a result of copious in-breeding. I vote neither.

[reply]
9/25/08

EXZombie

Number one looks like a healthy Norm McDonald and number two seems fake.

I thought you gals would be drooling over a Brad Pitt or Johnny Depp but I find you drooling over Norm McDonald and a 007 reject. Shame on you all.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  legbamel
  
  Heh, I haven't seen much drooling in this thread. It's mostly been a debate about which is the least unattractive.
9/25/08

rainforestrobin

I vote for #1 because his face shows some character. #2 is all flash and show but you can't really see any of him in his face. He's hidden behind the pose and the "look" and all the rest. Where #2 has a face I see into, I can see something of him and his character. And that is said from a place of: If I had to choose! And even then I've learned not to choose on looks alone.....that is only a teeny portion of a person.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Did you leave your vote in the voting poll?
9/25/08

ThriftShopRomantic

Probably the first guy, because the other guy is trying too hard. He is his own Glamour Shot.

If we're going by looks alone though... I'm going with MPDZombie's suggestion-- I'd rather look at Johnny Depp.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Please, vote in the poll, that'll keep the count right. Vote for the least unattractive if you have to. Thank you
9/25/08

aningeniousname

Bachelor number one looks like the kind of guy who hangs around parks with loose shorts, a bag of sweets and a come hither look, so I will definitely have to say he is the hottest.

[reply]
9/25/08

PetMono

is that it? judging the book by the cover? no way to tell unless you can see the walk and hear the talk. ok. you gotme. the fem legs in an early 007 poster was pretty hot.

[reply]
9/25/08

kat822

the first one , he has more character, second guy is too sissy

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  Kat,
  
  did you leave a vote in the post? Thank you!
9/25/08

contentconnection

i voted for the first one! he looks real.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  thank you for participating!
9/25/08

earthlingorgeous

I don't feel for any of the two lol

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  I made a mistake. I should have put three check boxes in case someone feels ewww about both
2. 9/25/08
  
  earthlingorgeous
  
  lol yeah hahahaha! I think they look so gay
9/25/08

Thoughts

I would vote for 1. Because of the look in his eyes. It looks like he's in love.

[reply]
9/25/08

Jeunelle

I can't make a decision until I met them in person and get to know them.
Looks can be deceiving and superficial and even though some of my girlfriends thinks Brad Pitt
is sexy. I don't necessarily think he is. Sorry I can't be of more help.

[reply]
1. 9/25/08
  
  ModelElaine
  
  fair enough
9/25/08

roadgurl5

That was tough but I voted for #1 as the least unattractive.

[reply]
9/25/08

ModelElaine

Thank you everyone who voted and participated in the discussion. We have counted the votes and removed the voting poll. In case you wondered guy #1 won 15 to 9 vote count. Thank you all again!

[reply]