Discussions

Cake. I couldn't live without cake. Or chicken sandwiches; I can't quit them. And there's no question I can't make it through life without chocolate!

(For proof, see an earlier discussion thread I posted:

www.blogcatalog.com/discuss/entry/so-what-goes-best-with-chocolate )

This is one of those, "If you were stranded on a desert island, what three foods would you have to take with you?" questions.

And why? What makes these foods special?

Reply

User Comments

  1. aningeniousname
    Ants, termites, and pie.
    1. gtally
      Mmmm. aardvarks love pie. Ant pie?
    2. aningeniousname
      Oh any kind of pie, I'm from the north of England and all we ever eat is pie and curry.
    3. busylizzy
      Grub pie.....mmmmmmmm!
    4. gtally
      Seriously, aningeniousname, what's your favorite pie, sweet or savory? Do you eat a lot of meat pies?
    5. aningeniousname
      I would have to go with the traditional English steak and kidney pie for savoury and the classic hot apple pie served with ice cream for sweet.
      There is actually a pie that squeezes together both of England's favourite foods, a Balti pie which is Balti curry in a pie.
    6. gtally
      OK, now you've raised a totally different question. What's in a Balti curry pie? And what's Balti curry? Explain it to a poor lost soul on the other side of the Atlantic...
    7. aningeniousname
      Balti curry is a mild curry served in a metal bowl (Balti means bucket in Urdu) in Indian restaurants here, it's a very popular dish.
      The Balti pie is just a normal pie but the filling is Balti curry.
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balti(food)
  2. CoyoteRose
    Cheeseburgers, potatoes and chocolate. I wouldn't take chocolate on a desert island with me, but i couldn't live without it in normal life. And potatoes are the all purpose food. You can make them a 100 different ways.
    1. scottmillerd
      Potatoe Pie for instance..
    2. gtally
      Any favorite potato dishes, CoyoteRose?
    3. CoyoteRose
      Not really. I love French fries and mashed potatoes mostly, but i could have them baked, julienned, scalloped, roasted. I mean thats what is so great about them in general.
    4. gtally
      After reading this, I had to run out and eat some French fries. CoyoteRose, you're a bad influence!
  3. melindaville
    Yogurt
    Bread
    Fruit
    1. gtally
      Very healthy. What flavor of yogurt? What kind of bread and fruit? And when are you going to start blogging about your taxi stories? Sorry, I'm a one note Nellie; i just really want to read about it. You've got me intrigued.
  4. LynneaUrania
    Wheat, soy, potato...these are the staples I use the most. If I was on a desert island, these are what I would propagate. The island itself would probably have resources of its own.
    1. gtally
      So you'd go into the gardening business. This is awesome because I never expected people to look at this silly question from a survivalist stance. I was picturing the cartoon island of a little hill of sand with one coconut palm and maybe a monkey. So what kind of soy would you eat LynneaUrania, edamame or curds or soy products, like soy hot dogs or something?
    2. LynneaUrania
      Why not the basic soybean? You can make everything else if you have that.

      If that island is the stereotypical rock with one coconut palm, I'd have to ask why that coconut palm still exists without saline poisoning. There would have to be a reservoir of fresh water beneath to allow it. If there's water, there's means to drink, clean, and to farm.

      The monkey would probably be roasted for food and his bones made into fish hooks after a week or so. When people are hungry, watch out!
    3. gtally
      Hah! I was visualizing a Gary Larson cartoon and you're approaching it like Tom Hanks from "Castaway." Really, really cool. It just goes to show you, there's always more than one way to the answer; it's the question that's the tricky part!
    4. LynneaUrania
      I never saw that movie. Nothing unusual for me, of course.
  5. sisterofmercy
    Bread, oranges and Pasta.
    1. gtally
      What kind of bread? What kind of pasta? Campanelle? Capunti? Casarecce? Cavatelli? Cechetti? Cencioni? Conchiglie? Conchiglioni? Corzetti? Creste di galli? Croxetti?

      And those are just the "C's"!

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_pasta
    2. gtally
      Everyone loves potatoes! Oops. Comment meant for cooltool below. Carry on, everybody...
  6. cooltool
    i wont answer but i can't live without potatoes
    1. sisterofmercy
      Technically that is an answer, not a complete answer but an answer nonetheless
  7. scottmillerd
    who would have thought that Potatoes would be so popular.
    1. LynneaUrania
      Why not? Potatoes saved the world at the Little Ice Age.
    2. scottmillerd
      Oh i think they are very good.
    3. LynneaUrania
      That too. Woof.
  8. kirewass
    Hmmm... let me think .. I don't "eat only to live", and treat food more than just some substance that helps me to survive...

    My answer:
    * Bananas, because I suffer from muscle cramps. Bananas alleviate the cramps.
    * Potatoes, because they are the one solid food stuff you can live longest on.
    * Plain black brewed coffee, because I'm addicted to coffee:)
    1. scottmillerd
      Bananas alleviate the cramps?
    2. busylizzy
      yes, bananas have potassium. If you are low on potassium you get cramps. I used to get charlie horses in my big toe!!! So weird, I know! Anyhoo - Eating a banana a day got rid of them.
    3. scottmillerd
      Charlie horses in your big toe?...hmm yeh that is weird.

      The left big toe or the right big toe? or both?..or did it alternate?
    4. busylizzy
      Scott - can't recall. It's been years and I don't dare go off bananas!
    5. scottmillerd
      Fair enough...as long as it helps ..then that's ..um Toe-riffic.
    6. Jeunelle
      Scientist also did studies which showed that cockroaches love bananas
      and/or the smell of bananas.
    7. gtally
      I've recently switched from coffee to tea, much against my will. I've been a black coffee drinker for ages, but for some reason my gag reflex started kicking in. Coffee was a very hard thing to walk away from...
  9. moreorlesley
    Hershey bars, cheeseburgers and fruit salad! lol
    1. gtally
      A well balanced meal, if there ever was one.
  10. Stillthinking
    I would say eggs, potatoes, spinach. Of course, I would end up dying of scurvy.
    1. gtally
      --Or making one helluva good breakfast omelette.
  11. cooltool
    Potatoes - as sexy as Pamela Anderson + Scarlet Johanson
    1. gtally
      Yes, potatoes are the sex pots of all the root tubers...
    1. gtally
      White, brown, wild rice? All of the above?
  12. kirewass
    Scottmillerd: Yes, "A banana a day keeps the cramps away". Bananas are rich in potassium, calcium, magnesium.

    I suffer from cramps in my calves and feet. I wake up with them. They sure do hurt. Cramps can be avoided by increasing the intake of calcium, potassium, and magnesium.
    1. scottmillerd
      Hm interesting ...i did not know that.
  13. MadMadMargo
    Brown rice, vegetables, fruits.
    1. gtally
      Healthy. Substitute that with chocolate fudge sundaes, Ho Hos and Twinkies and I'm right there with you.
  14. busylizzy
    1. Chips and salsa
    2. Potatos of any form but my first love is for mashed potatos, esp garlic mashed potatos. They are my comfort food.
    3. Spaghetti
    1. gtally
      This thread has a theme. Everybody loves the spuds!
  15. Shuttercraft
    Eggs!
    Fish!
    Durian!
    1. gtally
      What kind of fish?
  16. kroegergirl
    Ummm...let me think.
    Cheesesteak subs....a sub that is made up of cheese and steak, and steak with cheese on top placed gently in between a submarine bun. Yep that's all three of them
    1. gtally
      Are you from Philly? Or just a cheese steak fancier?
    2. kroegergirl
      Nope...I just recently became a vegetarian and I'm hungry :-)
  17. scottmillerd
    how about

    Orange Jello
    Grape Jello
    Cherry Jello
    1. gtally
      Sounds like the beginning of any cafeteria line, with the Jello line-up sitting there on crushed ice. I always liked to get this weird concoction of molded Jello salad that was mint green. If memory serves me correctly, the mold was green Jello, cream, walnuts and pineapple. Not bad, for Jello.
  18. Theresa111
    Too hard to choose!
    1. gtally
      Well then, just bring the whole fridge.
  19. timethief
    grains, nuts, vegetables, fruits
    1. gtally
      Hey that's four. Sneaky, timethief, sneaky. Could you give up one food for a trifecta? Or is it an all or nothing proposition?
    2. timethief
      Nah there are vegies that some think are fruits & visa versa so it's a three ...
  20. dinsquared
    I could give up almost anything if it was going to kill me. I couldn't give up chocolate or beef...or...maybe cheese.
    1. gtally
      Don't eat beef, but I've loudly declared my undying love for chocolate and cheese in some other discussion threads. They're all listed above in the related topics section of this discussion, if you're interested.
  21. anicam
    forget it i can't do without my daily yoghurt
    1. gtally
      Any particular flavor of yogurt?
  22. dosox
    WATER salads WATER
    1. gtally
      You must be as skinny as a rake, eating that healthy!
  23. fruitcake
    Meat, veggies, and chocolate...specifically steak, broccoli, and Heath bars.
    1. gtally
      Yay for the broccoli and Heath Bars! But I don't eat the steak, and stay away from beef of all kinds. (Afraid of Mad Cow disease).
  24. JaydenVasara
    grilled chicken, produce, protein bars, wine
    1. gtally
      That's *four*, SC. Give up the protein bars, the others taste too good.
    2. JaydenVasara
      oops! for some reason i saw 4 instead of 3.... apparently i should've put coffee on the list and left it at that
  25. Kiwipulse
    1. Big Mac
    2. Mac Chicken
    3. Poutine ( French fried with gravy and BBQ sauce )

    I know, I know it's all junk food. But I cant find a purpose in life without them!

    KIWIPULSE // EVOLUTION OF ART
    www.kiwipulse.com
    1. gtally
      My God, you must be from Quebec! Poutine is like the best junk food ever. Fell in love with the stuff last time I was in Montreal. Good answers.
  26. Lifeposter
    1. cadburys Chocolate
    2. Chocolate cake
    3. Chocolate milkshake
    1. gtally
      Lifeposter, you are a BC member after my own heart. All hail the mighty chocolate!
  27. IntoTheAzureSea
    Fruit juices, Bread, Beef........
    1. gtally
      What kind of bread? What kind of juice?
  28. Lunais
    Vanilla Milkshake, sushi, tandoori chicken
    1. gtally
      Yum. Tandoori chicken is amazing. I think I'll go out for some Indian food this weekend. Thanks for the suggestion!
  29. acousticguitarist
    Rice, Legumes or Tofu, leafy greens
    1. gtally
      Is that your diet, acousticguitarist, or is that for your Red Panda avatar?
  30. IntoTheAzureSea
    Damn it, i wish i had a medium grilled steak right now.....
    1. acousticguitarist
      why don't you go and get one?
  31. phantomelen
    Icecream........icecream......and ....ya.............ICECREAM!!!!!
    1. gtally
      That's it, scream for that ice cream! What are the flavors of the three scoops in your triple decker ice cream cone?
  32. drjay1966
    Whatever's in my fridge
    Whatever's in the kitchen cabinet
    Whatever else I can scrounge up in the kitchen

    They're special because I'm feeling too lazy to go out and get anything else...
    1. gtally
      Go for some Chinese delivery, drjay1966. And if you have a TiVo, you can now order a pizza through your TV. Ah, progress...
  33. umarpirzada
    Not a food person even though I have put on some weight in the recent past. Need sweets after every meal, love chicken and meat.
    1. gtally
      What kind of meat? And yes, dessert is a *right*, not a privilege.
  34. livtotravel
    rice, meat, vegetables
    please visit my blog at www.livtotravel.blogspot.com.
    thank you
    1. gtally
      Nice blog, livtotravel. Can you be more specific on what kinds of meat and veggies?
  35. xaheer
    i can't live without all the
    sweetish, saltish and watery delights

    visit my blog at
    www.enginehour.com
    blog.enginehour.com
    1. gtally
      I agree on sweet, disagree on salty. And what do you mean by waterish?
  36. lulubelleb
    Yogurt, oatmeal, green tea.
    1. gtally
      I'm a black tea drinker, myself, although I do occasionally enjoy some green.
  37. DangerMouse
    Oranges, Cheerios and grilled chicken
    1. gtally
      That's breakfast and lunch covered, right there. But what's for dinner?
  38. idevourfashion
    salade greens
    chicken
    chocolate cake
    1. gtally
      Yes, yes, yes, idevourfashion! Bring on the chocolate cake! And pile it high with gooey chocolate frosting!
  39. easyatomicmess
    wine, cake, cheese I cant live without those. But to be practical probebley fresh, water, water, and more water.
    1. gtally
      Awwwwww. you're no fun. Don't be practical. Let's go with door number one and enjoy the wine, cake and cheese.
  40. sunnyberra
    Potatoe pancakes, chicken, and tilapia. Yum
    1. gtally
      You're the first person who's said tilapia. It has the potential of being one of the few environmentally safe farm-raised fishes that doesn't promote overfishing. Unfortunately, there's only one fish farm in the U.S. and the rest are in China, and are sources of heavy pollution. Great answer!
  41. amberafternoon
    Spinach, Apples, Cheese.

    1. gtally
      Yum! That could be a really good salad, maybe with a little honey mustard vinaigrette...
  42. radioflyer1980
    While none of these would be all that good on a desert island, they are three foods I find it hard to live without.

    1) Cheese and sausage deep dish pizza from Lou Malnati's. It's tart tomatoes and cornbread crust piled high with mozzarella cheese. It also helps that I go there when I have friends from out of town.
    2) Hot dogs from Portillo's. A mark of a good hot dog is if you can order it plain - nothing on it except a poppy seed bun - and it still tastes like something. Portillo's has a dog with a secret recipe courtesy of Vienna Beef that I've never been able to replicate (though a mix of chili pepper, oregano, black pepper and other spices seems to come close).
    3) Sliders from White Castle. What can I say? It's 3:00 in the morning and you're coming off something enjoyable, where else can you go but White Castle and pick up a "sack" (actual measuring unit of Sliders).

    Upon reviewing this list, it could explain why I'm on Weight Watchers!
    1. gtally
      Wow, they all sound incredible! Where are Lou Malnati's and Portillo's?
  43. danj88x
    Pizza
    Cheeseburgers
    Shrimp
    1. gtally
      Love shrimp, especially tiger prawns.
  44. Jendyptp
    Big decisions! Has to be potatoes, chicken and definitely chocolate x
    1. gtally
      What kind of chocolate?
  45. godsprincess
    Bread, cheese and rice crackers!
    1. gtally
      That meal would make you thirsty!
  46. barry1234
    My three favorites foods at my age are Royal Gala Apples, Roast Chicken and good old Pumpkin Pie.
    1. gtally
      Gala apples are one of my favorites, and I can't believe no one has said pumpkin pie, yet! With whipped cream, or without?
  47. HeadStones
    Choclate, Pizza and Ribs but ask that question in a nother year and it all mite change but the choclate.
    1. gtally
      Sounds like a good meal out at a neighborhood sports bar. Could be a lot of fun!
  48. dgnitzky
    rice cakes, fruits and vegetables are my favorite foods
    1. gtally
      Healthy, healthy, healthy. Do you have any favorite junk foods?
  49. annz
    coffee, cheese, chocolate (huh, they all start with "c" coindcidence?). But I suppose that wouldn't keep me alive on a desert island for long (happy and alert, though). On the island, I guess I'd want coconuts, limes and fish. That should cover a lot of the nutrients, plus, I could do a nice fish stew with it.
    1. gtally
      Well, I couldn't live without the most expensive coffee in the world:

      www.blogcatalog.com/discuss/entry/most-expensive-coffee-in-the-world

      Sorry folks, you just have to check it out!
    2. gtally
      I'm sorry, you deserve a more respectful answer, as well. Your first three foods sounds like a nice before dinner coffee party. Your desert island foods sound like a really good Thai dish!
  50. HanamiGallery
    beef, rice, and cake
    1. gtally
      What kind of cake? My favorite is chocolate.
  51. TonyB
    chocolate
    1. gtally
      Bad, TonyB! Chocolate is bad for dogs!
  52. ophase
    Olive, rice, yogurt
    1. gtally
      What kind of olives? I like Kalamata the best.
  53. karenlloyd
    Olives, mayonnaise and curry
    1. gtally
      Nothing better than a good, hot curry.
  54. GlobetrottingBride
    Peanut butter, potato chips and ice cream!
    1. gtally
      GlobetrottingBride, you're a junk food junkie after my own heart. What flavor of ice cream?
  55. JamCan
    Jamaican food, Mexican food, pizza.
    1. gtally
      You know, I must remind people of Jamaican food because they keep calling me a great big jerk. As for Mexican food, I love refried beans and rice, and pozolé soup!
  56. selfdevelopment
    rice, laksa, curry
    1. gtally
      What's laska? Never heard of it before!
  57. AnthonySepe
    Chicken; fruits and baked potato
    Thanks,
    ~Anthony
    1. gtally
      Baked chicken? Or fried? And what kind of fruit?
  58. Kastina
    Potatoes, Chocolate and mint.
    1. gtally
      Fresh mint sounds pretty good to me, too. Or would you eat chocolate chip mint ice cream?
  59. cookiejeans
    rice, banana, dried fish
    1. gtally
      Dried fish? Now you've intrigued me. What kind of dried fish?
  60. makeshiftspaces
    rice, mac and cheese and strawberries
    1. gtally
      That's a complete meal, right there. Nothing beats fresh strawberries!
  61. SweetViolet
    Chocolate, fresh fruit, pasta.
    1. gtally
      What kind of fruit and pasta?
  62. MadamX
    Steak, potatoes and Red Vines
    1. gtally
      Ah ha ha ha ha! Red Vines the licorice sticks? Seriously awesome answer!
  63. insomia
    butter croissont, chocolate and apple pie^^
    1. gtally
      How about a chocolate croissant? One of my favorites. French pastry is the main reason I tolerate the French.
  64. idealpinkrose
    pie, nuts, fruits
    1. gtally
      How about fruit nut pie? You could east everything in one dish!
  65. ranist22
    Rice, potatoes, lentilles!
    1. gtally
      Lentils are great. What's your favorite way of cooking them?
  66. lovelyrainbow1
    rice
    eggs
    steak
    1. gtally
      I like a hard boiled egg with just a little bit of yellow mustard.
  67. hazirahkatrina
    1) 3/4 boiled egg because its so delicious
    2) Fish because its so fresh
    3) Chicken because its so tasty
    thetruthoflife-hazirah.blogspot.com/
  68. Wowmomma
    Coffee, coffee and ummm....COFFEE!
  69. legbamel
    I'd bring coffee, potatoes (the little red ones), and cheese (cojack, if I have to pick a particular kind, as it's mild enough to enjoy with any...kind of potato, but I'd love to bring an assortment, with some gouda and some extra-sharp cheddar).
    1. legbamel
      I've decided that, as coffee is a beverage rather than a food, I'll change that part of my answer to chicken. I can think of many ways to prepare chicken, cheese, and potatoes, separately and in combination, as well as the fact that live chickens will provide me with eggs. It's too bad I can't grow a cheese tree, though.
  70. DavidW
    bread vegetable fruit
  71. DavidW
    bread vegetable fruit
  72. wagerwitch
    Sheesh --- ok - fine - I didn't answer it then - but now I will.

    I have to have these things to survive:

    Pretzels, Dr. Pepper, Pasta Dripping in Butter salt and Pepper.
  73. waitinginthedark
    chocolate, pasta, vegetables
  74. Rainhat
    Sushi
    Meat
    Pancakes
  75. Kasumi
    Chilli
    Coffee
    Chicken
  76. vnfriend
    Rice, meat and vegetable

    Rice is the main food in daily meals in our country, although we also enjoy bread and noodle...

    Meat and vegetable make rice more enjoyable!
  77. cazywaz
    Mac n' Cheese
    Cous Cous
    Spicy curries
  78. cil
    Rice
    Fish
    Chicken
  79. trailofpen
    Marinara sauce, fresh baguette, and cured meats.
  80. scenexg
    easy!! lasagna, cheese burgers, buffalo wings. done! lol
  81. celticmusicfan
    sushi,hotdogs,eggs

Add Your Comment

Login to leave a message.