Discussions

What makes a good comment?

Posted by arkafle • 10/25/09 • Subscribe to this Discussion [RSS] • Report This Topic
Topics: blog, comment, good

I try to comment some interesting blog that i find. But every time i get unsatisfied with what I've written and i erase it. So how does comment looks like.

User Comments

10/25/09

crazyTsu

Brevity.
If a single line could convey as much as a lengthy explanation, find it and use it.

[reply]
1. 10/25/09
  
  arkafle
  
  thanks for replying
  yes short comment looks nice.
10/25/09

HollytheHousewife

Awweee,u should just write what ur heart tells u to write. That is what makes what u write right!!!

[reply]
1. 10/25/09
  
  arkafle
  
  thanks for replying
10/25/09

ChampDog

Yupe, as long as from our honest comments or opinion that should be considered a the good one.

[reply]
1. 10/25/09
  
  arkafle
  
  thanks for replying
10/25/09

Firkroy

I usually only comment on things that I like. I like to point out the things that I like best.

[reply]
1. 10/25/09
  
  arkafle
  
  thanks for replying
10/25/09

cookingasshole

full frontal

[reply]
1. 10/25/09
  
  sorcerer
  
  well said...full frontal that is
10/25/09

crawler

In general.

[reply]
10/25/09

nothingprofound

Acknowledgement and appreciation.

[reply]
1. 10/26/09
  
  transpoengineer
  
  I agree with it... Acknowledge the post of the blogger and appreciate it.
10/25/09

Rivy

Depends on the response triggered. Sometimes I comment with one liners. Other times a thought or story might be triggered that takes a paragraph or two.

[reply]
10/25/09

petchatter

Yeah, what Holly said. Just your honest reaction is most appreciated. The ones I hate are those spammy "I will be your constant reader" drones.

[reply]
1. 10/25/09
  
  arkafle
  
  yea i hate spammy (irrelevant and short)
  comments, especially those with urls at the bottom.
10/26/09

cityrambler

Agree with nothingprofund 'acknowledgement and appreciation'. Something that adds value to the post above. Spammy comments are a no, no as petchatter and arkafle point out.

[reply]